You know, I think Monk is a very polarizing show. Episodes are either extremely good or extremely bad; there is no in-between.
I forgot I didn't like Mr. Monk Fights City Hall and we ended up watching it last night. The councilwoman's aide really was kind of a dolt, but Mr. Monk was a jerk to her during the reveal of the bad guy scene. What's sad, though, is that he just doesn't have good people skills and honestly didn't even stop to think about what he was saying until it was too late. And of course, she was indignant and decided to change her vote about helping him keep the parking lot where Trudy died instead of voting to tear it down. And all of that was played for laughs, like "Ha Ha, Mr. Monk is such a jerk, now he gets what he deserves," and yet then the epilogue immediately following is serious and sad as he looks at the spot where Trudy died and then leaves the parking lot with Natalie (and at least we see the new playground will be named for Trudy). But seriously, the tone shift doesn't work. First we're supposed to laugh at him and feel like he deserves what he's getting, then in the next instant we're supposed to feel sad for him that he's losing something so dear to him because of a split-second slip-up? Not to mention, first it's supposed to be funny that he loses the parking garage and then it isn't? Make up your minds, people! It doesn't work both ways.
It's amazing how well M*A*S*H and other old shows worked as comedy-dramas. Sometimes I really don't think Monk grasps how to do it properly. But then we see a great episode like Mr. Monk is Underwater and it becomes clear that the writers do know how to do it (although I do question them deciding to use Monk's coping mechanism of pretending Dr. Bell is there as something humorous, but at least there it was a more gentle humor and not played nasty). Perhaps some writers get it and some don't. Or sometimes a good writer has an off-day. In any case, ugh, I detest episodes like the city hall one.
Then I ponder on the psychiatrist question. I loved Dr. Bell from the moment I saw him years ago, but the more I re-watch his episodes, the more I wonder if I actually like him more than Dr. Kroger. It really seems like Dr. Bell is more personable and friendly and maybe actually likes Monk better than Dr. Kroger did. But I suppose it's just different personalities and different methods; Dr. Kroger had some really poignant scenes, like the one where he tells Monk that he would never write in a file that a patient is beyond hope; he always believes there's hope. I do really like that they write the characters differently so Dr. Bell isn't just a carbon copy of Dr. Kroger.
And I'd forgotten how nasty Natalie was in her very first episodes, especially that crack about Monk being the Prince of Darkness because murder always finds him. I don't even think Sharona would have said something like that in her worst moments. I'm really glad they decided not to make Natalie nastier than Sharona and instead decided to make her less abrasive.
On Thursday I finally got to go see about a gift certificate I had for Build a Bear. It expires next week, but I wanted to go this week because there was a sale I wanted to use with my certificate. I got this gorgeous blue bear for $10 on the sale, and that was the exact amount of my certificate, so I didn't have to pay anything. LOL. It's the bear they designed based on Thomas the Tank Engine; I've wanted it since I first got the announcement about its release. I just adore all shades of blue! Then I found that Target had finally got in the new wave of the retro My Little Pony re-releases and I brought home the pink Twilight (who was a partial inspiration for Twilight Sparkle, and as it is, Twilight Sparkle's mother is designed similar to Twilight). I have been so happy to have Twilight, more than I even thought I would be, and I think I figured out why. She looks very similar to a Pony called Milky Way, only in person Milky Way isn't the color she is in the pictures, and as a kid all I had were the pictures and I dreamed desperately of owning that Pony. I think she was my second biggest grail after Sugarberry. When I finally got Milky Way, I loved her dearly, but was a little sad she didn't look exactly like the pictures in shade of pink. Twilight does, and I think that woke up the little kid in me who wanted the Pony who looked like that. I am just squeeing all over to have her. I set her on the desktop monitor that's behind the laptop, so I can look at her constantly while at the computer. I'm so glad I didn't buy that original Twilight years ago with the loose washer rolling around inside her. I never wanted to buy a Pony in that condition, but I waffled on that because it was a good price and since I'd already expressed interest in her, but I was relieved to not have to go through with the sale when I learned about the loose washer. It is sooo much better to be able to buy the 1980s Ponies new! I hope the releases will keep coming.
(LOL, I still haven't switched back to the desktop once since getting my external DVD-ROM for the laptop. I've meant to, and I need to in order to watch movies since the laptop doesn't have enough power for the external to run on for anything that takes a lot of memory like a movie, but I just far prefer using the laptop and I haven't been able to make myself switch since the external runs good enough for TV show episodes, which is what I usually want to watch.)
I forgot I didn't like Mr. Monk Fights City Hall and we ended up watching it last night. The councilwoman's aide really was kind of a dolt, but Mr. Monk was a jerk to her during the reveal of the bad guy scene. What's sad, though, is that he just doesn't have good people skills and honestly didn't even stop to think about what he was saying until it was too late. And of course, she was indignant and decided to change her vote about helping him keep the parking lot where Trudy died instead of voting to tear it down. And all of that was played for laughs, like "Ha Ha, Mr. Monk is such a jerk, now he gets what he deserves," and yet then the epilogue immediately following is serious and sad as he looks at the spot where Trudy died and then leaves the parking lot with Natalie (and at least we see the new playground will be named for Trudy). But seriously, the tone shift doesn't work. First we're supposed to laugh at him and feel like he deserves what he's getting, then in the next instant we're supposed to feel sad for him that he's losing something so dear to him because of a split-second slip-up? Not to mention, first it's supposed to be funny that he loses the parking garage and then it isn't? Make up your minds, people! It doesn't work both ways.
It's amazing how well M*A*S*H and other old shows worked as comedy-dramas. Sometimes I really don't think Monk grasps how to do it properly. But then we see a great episode like Mr. Monk is Underwater and it becomes clear that the writers do know how to do it (although I do question them deciding to use Monk's coping mechanism of pretending Dr. Bell is there as something humorous, but at least there it was a more gentle humor and not played nasty). Perhaps some writers get it and some don't. Or sometimes a good writer has an off-day. In any case, ugh, I detest episodes like the city hall one.
Then I ponder on the psychiatrist question. I loved Dr. Bell from the moment I saw him years ago, but the more I re-watch his episodes, the more I wonder if I actually like him more than Dr. Kroger. It really seems like Dr. Bell is more personable and friendly and maybe actually likes Monk better than Dr. Kroger did. But I suppose it's just different personalities and different methods; Dr. Kroger had some really poignant scenes, like the one where he tells Monk that he would never write in a file that a patient is beyond hope; he always believes there's hope. I do really like that they write the characters differently so Dr. Bell isn't just a carbon copy of Dr. Kroger.
And I'd forgotten how nasty Natalie was in her very first episodes, especially that crack about Monk being the Prince of Darkness because murder always finds him. I don't even think Sharona would have said something like that in her worst moments. I'm really glad they decided not to make Natalie nastier than Sharona and instead decided to make her less abrasive.
On Thursday I finally got to go see about a gift certificate I had for Build a Bear. It expires next week, but I wanted to go this week because there was a sale I wanted to use with my certificate. I got this gorgeous blue bear for $10 on the sale, and that was the exact amount of my certificate, so I didn't have to pay anything. LOL. It's the bear they designed based on Thomas the Tank Engine; I've wanted it since I first got the announcement about its release. I just adore all shades of blue! Then I found that Target had finally got in the new wave of the retro My Little Pony re-releases and I brought home the pink Twilight (who was a partial inspiration for Twilight Sparkle, and as it is, Twilight Sparkle's mother is designed similar to Twilight). I have been so happy to have Twilight, more than I even thought I would be, and I think I figured out why. She looks very similar to a Pony called Milky Way, only in person Milky Way isn't the color she is in the pictures, and as a kid all I had were the pictures and I dreamed desperately of owning that Pony. I think she was my second biggest grail after Sugarberry. When I finally got Milky Way, I loved her dearly, but was a little sad she didn't look exactly like the pictures in shade of pink. Twilight does, and I think that woke up the little kid in me who wanted the Pony who looked like that. I am just squeeing all over to have her. I set her on the desktop monitor that's behind the laptop, so I can look at her constantly while at the computer. I'm so glad I didn't buy that original Twilight years ago with the loose washer rolling around inside her. I never wanted to buy a Pony in that condition, but I waffled on that because it was a good price and since I'd already expressed interest in her, but I was relieved to not have to go through with the sale when I learned about the loose washer. It is sooo much better to be able to buy the 1980s Ponies new! I hope the releases will keep coming.
(LOL, I still haven't switched back to the desktop once since getting my external DVD-ROM for the laptop. I've meant to, and I need to in order to watch movies since the laptop doesn't have enough power for the external to run on for anything that takes a lot of memory like a movie, but I just far prefer using the laptop and I haven't been able to make myself switch since the external runs good enough for TV show episodes, which is what I usually want to watch.)